Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Replace Toilet Fill Valve

Two  of my daughters have complained that the toilet in the back bedroom was making a whining noise and not fully turning off.  Examining the inside of the tank on the back of the toilet revealed that the fill valve apparently had a slow leak at the top where the float lever is supposed to turn off the water after a flush.  So it's time to replace the fill valve.

A photo of the current fill valve and a trip to Home Depot gets us a replacement, the Fluidmaster 400A Toilet Fill Valve.  Which it turns out is actually stamped in the plastic on the existing one.

The exact same part, for about $10.  Looking now, we replaced this part in Nov 2014, after being installed in June 2004. So these fill valves last about 10 to 12 years.

The process is pretty straightforward.  Turn off the water.  Flush the toilet to drain the tank.  That still leaves about 3 gallons of water to scoop out with a cup and then sponge or towel to soak up the rest.


 Then remove the old fill valve.


 And put in the new one and turn on the water.


Then clean up, and we're done.  Takes about an hour.